When Anthem Insurance Covers Blepharoplasty: The Importance of MRD Under 2 mm

Blepharoplasty—commonly known as eyelid surgery—is a highly effective procedure performed to correct drooping eyelids, remove excess eyelid skin, and restore both function and appearance to the eyes. While this surgery is often performed for cosmetic purposes, it can also be medically necessary in cases where drooping eyelids interfere with vision. Insurance companies, including Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield, often cover blepharoplasty when specific medical criteria are met. A central factor in determining medical necessity is a measurement called the Margin Reflex Distance (MRD)—especially when MRD is less than 2 millimeters (mm).

This article delves into when Anthem covers blepharoplasty, how MRD under 2 mm plays a vital role in that decision, and why this seemingly small measurement has big implications for patient care and insurance approval.

Understanding Blepharoplasty: Functional vs. Cosmetic

Blepharoplasty is a surgical procedure that addresses issues with the upper and/or lower eyelids. It may involve removing redundant skin, repositioning fat pads, or tightening muscles. There are two broad indications for this surgery:

1. Cosmetic Blepharoplasty

This is performed purely to improve appearance. Common goals include reducing signs of aging, correcting asymmetry, or enhancing eye shape. Since cosmetic blepharoplasty is considered elective, Anthem does not cover it under standard health insurance policies.

2. Functional (Medical) Blepharoplasty

This is performed to restore visual function when drooping eyelids obstruct the visual field. In this scenario, the surgery is no longer optional—it becomes medically necessary. Anthem and other insurers may cover it if strict clinical criteria are met. These include:

• Visual field obstruction

• Photographic evidence of ptosis

• Medical documentation of symptoms

• MRD measurement below 2 mm

Let’s examine why MRD is one of the most important factors Anthem considers when approving coverage.

What Is Margin Reflex Distance (MRD)?

Margin Reflex Distance (MRD) is a clinical measurement that helps determine how much the upper eyelid is drooping. It’s measured from the corneal light reflex (the reflection of light on the cornea when a penlight is shined) to the upper eyelid margin.

There are two relevant values:

• MRD1: Upper eyelid to corneal light reflex (used to evaluate ptosis)

• MRD2: Lower eyelid to corneal light reflex (less relevant for coverage)

Normal vs. Abnormal MRD1 Values

• Normal MRD1: 4–5 mm

• Mild Ptosis: 2–3 mm

• Significant Ptosis: < 2 mm

An MRD1 below 2 mm suggests that the upper eyelid is severely drooping and is likely obstructing the pupil—especially when the patient is in primary gaze. Anthem uses this threshold as an objective clinical benchmark for approving medically necessary blepharoplasty.

Why MRD Under 2 mm Matters for Insurance Coverage

Anthem’s medical policy guidelines emphasize that for blepharoplasty to be covered, it must correct a functional problem, not simply a cosmetic one. One of the most common functional problems is superior visual field loss, which can be directly linked to a low MRD measurement.

When MRD Is Under 2 mm:

• It objectively supports the diagnosis of ptosis or dermatochalasis causing functional impairment.

• It validates patient-reported symptoms like:

  • Eyes feeling heavy

  • Needing to tilt the head back to see

  • Using the forehead muscles to lift the brow

  • Fatigue and headaches from visual strain

• It often correlates with defects on visual field testing, which Anthem requires as further proof.

Thus, MRD is not just a number—it’s a medically measurable indicator of when surgery is warranted.

Anthem’s Blepharoplasty Coverage Criteria

To be considered for coverage, patients typically must meet all of the following criteria:

1. Clinical Documentation of SymptomsThe patient must report functional issues such as:

   • Obstructed vision in the upper field

   • Interference with daily activities (driving, reading, etc.)

   • Chronic forehead strain

2. Photographic EvidencePhotos must show the eyelid margin at or below the pupil in primary gaze. Anthem often requests:

   • Frontal view with natural brow position

   • Eyelids open and closed

   • Lateral view to show skin redundancy

3. MRD1 Under 2 mmAs discussed, this measurement demonstrates severity and helps differentiate medical vs. cosmetic need.

4. Visual Field TestingA formal visual field test (e.g., Humphrey or Goldman) must demonstrate a loss of at least 12–30 degrees in the superior field of vision. Often, improvement must also be demonstrated when the excess lid is taped.

5. Surgeon RecommendationA written statement by the ophthalmologist or oculoplastic surgeon indicating medical necessity based on the clinical findings.

The MRD-Based Pathway to Approval

Here’s how the MRD measurement fits into a successful insurance approval process with Anthem:

Step	Description
1	Patient presents with symptoms of visual obstruction.
2	MRD is measured and documented (MRD1 < 2 mm).
3	Visual field test confirms superior visual loss.
4	Photographs show eyelid at or below the pupil.
5	Provider submits all evidence with a pre-authorization request.
6	Anthem reviews the documentation against their policy.
7	Coverage is approved if all criteria are met.

Common Reasons for Denial—and How MRD Helps Prevent Them

Insurance denials can be frustrating, especially when patients clearly suffer from eyelid drooping. Understanding how MRD under 2 mm strengthens a claim can help providers and patients avoid common pitfalls.

Common Denial Reasons:

1. Insufficient evidence of functional impairment

2. No MRD documented

3. Photos suggest cosmetic concern only

4. Visual field test is normal

5. No improvement with taped eyelid

How MRD Protects Against Denials:

• Offers objective, measurable proof of eyelid drooping.

• Provides a quantifiable clinical finding that correlates with visual field obstruction.

• Serves as a key threshold in Anthem’s policy guidelines.

• Helps justify pre-authorization requests in borderline cases.

Real-World Case Example

Patient: 68-year-old woman with chronic forehead strain, difficulty reading, and driving at night.

Findings:

• MRD1: 1.5 mm bilaterally

• Visual field: Superior field loss of 22 degrees

• Taped test: 80% improvement in visual field

• Clinical photos: Show upper eyelids at the mid-pupil

Outcome:

• Surgeon submitted all documentation.

• Anthem approved blepharoplasty as medically necessary.

• Patient experienced dramatic improvement in symptoms post-surgery.

This example highlights the power of MRD under 2 mm in validating medical necessity and ensuring insurance support.

Surgical Options for Low MRD

When the MRD is less than 2 mm and the surgery is approved, the surgical plan may vary:

• External ptosis repair (levator advancement or resection)

• Functional upper lid blepharoplasty to remove redundant skin and/or fat

• Combination procedures, especially in older patients

Surgeons often tailor their approach based on:

• Degree of levator muscle function

• Skin laxity

• Coexisting brow ptosis or other anatomic factors

The goal is always the same: relieve functional impairment, and if needed, improve aesthetics secondarily.

Post-Surgical Outcomes for Functional Blepharoplasty

Patients who undergo medically necessary blepharoplasty often report:

• Improved upper peripheral vision

• Reduced forehead muscle strain

• Decreased eye fatigue

• Better ability to read, work, and drive

• Psychological benefits from a more open, rested appearance

When MRD is the key factor guiding surgery, both function and satisfaction rates are high—making it one of the most meaningful small measurements in oculoplastic surgery.

Conclusion: MRD Under 2 mm—A Small Number with Big Significance

Anthem covers blepharoplasty only when it’s medically necessary. MRD under 2 mm is one of the most critical criteria in defining that necessity. It is not merely a number but a clinically meaningful measurement that bridges the gap between patient symptoms, objective evidence, and insurance approval.

For patients and providers alike, understanding the importance of MRD can:

• Streamline the insurance approval process

• Prevent denials

• Clarify the medical rationale for surgery

• Ensure timely, effective treatment for those truly in need

If you or your patient suffers from vision impairment due to drooping eyelids, a carefully documented MRD under 2 mm may be the key to unlocking access to medically necessary, life-enhancing care.

Would you like this article adapted for use as a handout or for a practice website?